10GbE and iSCSI – Delivering Affordable Options

Last week a friend and I were talking about our children and the conversation turned to affordable options for college. It turns out my friend’s daughter is doing very well in school and eager to study agriculture, but is applying to only a couple state universities. I suggested that she should keep her options open and also apply to top agriculture schools like Cornell, but at $50,000/year cost is a major issue and sadly the reality is that colleges are becoming less and less affordable each year.

So it wasn’t enough for my friend’s daughter to have options, she needed affordable ones. I found myself comparing the college admissions world with my world, that of Information Technology, and thought how fortunate we were that technology breakthroughs like 10GbE not only provide improvements in performance and quality of service, but do so while delivering affordable options.

Let me explain.

First, it’s important to recognize the transition from 1GbE to 10GbE is happening now. Several factors are driving this transition, and with server virtualization, there is strong market demand for 10GbE. In fact, according to a May 2010 IT Brand Pulse survey, nearly two-thirds of the questioned IT managers indicated they had or were in the process of deploying 10GbE and half said server virtualization was driving the adoption of 10GbE.

Reality is that 10GbE is already being integrated and deployed onto motherboards with server manufacturers launching 10GbE as LAN on Motherboard (LOM) solutions on blade, rack, and tower servers. Furthermore, in their July 2010 report, the Dell’Oro Group estimated that 13.4M servers will ship with a 10GbE LOM by 2014 up from 0.5M in 2009 – they predicted that sometime in or during the back half of 2012, servers with 10GbE will outnumber those shipping with 1GbE. Additionally, the overall 10GbE per-port-pricing is already less than $400 and expected to drop further as 10GBaseT solutions are introduced.

But what does this mean for storage?

It comes down to affordable options and with 10GbE, there are multiple IP storage protocols to access both file and block data and 10GbE iSCSI is very compelling as there are even more options from which to choose. The standard baseline today is that operating systems provide an iSCSI software initiator that is essentially along with most standard operating systems and runs on most 10GbE NICs – sort of the basic converged 10GbE model.

To offload the server CPUs, for straightforward booting from an iSCSI SAN, and especially for enterprise-class manageability, converged iSCSI adapters that run both NIC and iSCSI offload are an option. In the past, this would have required the purchase of an iSCSI adapter. But today, some 10GbE LOMs and NICs can provide iSCSI adapter functionality as part of their standard offering or through a pay-as-you-go upgrade model.

So when you’re buying your server especially if you’re planning to use it for virtualization, for basic I/O scalability you should consider the benefits of a server with a 10GbE LOM and remember that it’ll also provide storage connectivity with an iSCSI software initiator. And if you’re undecided whether you need the benefits of an iSCSI adapter but want to keep your options open, keep in mind that some server LOM solutions already support iSCSI offload or can be upgraded to support it. This way, you have a 10GbE solution with built in affordable options for iSCSI.

I know this is somewhat of a stretch from the world of colleges and unfortunately 10GbE doesn’t help my friend’s daughter, but I do hope that she sees the value of having options and applies to Cornell – you never know if a scholarship or financial aid might come through and give her that affordable option.

Ethernet and IP Storage – Today’s Technology Enabling Next Generation Data Centers

I continue to believe that IP based storage protocols will be preferred for future data center deployments. The future of IT is pointing to cloud based architectures, whether internal or external. At the core of the cloud is virtualization. And I believe that Ethernet and IP storage protocols offer the greatest overall value to unlock the potential of virtualization and clouds. Will other storage network technologies work? Of course. But, I’m not talking about whether a network “works”. I’m suggesting that a converged network environment with Ethernet and IP storage offers the best combined value for virtual environments and cloud deployments. I’ve written and spoken about this topic before. And I will likely continue to do so. So, let me mention a few reasons to choose IP storage, iSCSI or NAS, for use in cloud environments.

Mobility. One of the many benefits of server virtualization is the ability to non-disruptively migrate applications from one physical server to another to support load balancing, failover or redundancy, and servicing or updating of hardware. The ability to migrate applications is best achieved with networked storage since the data doesn’t have to move when a virtual machine (VM) moves. But, the network needs to maintain connectivity to the fabric when a VM moves. Ethernet offers a network technology capable of migrating or reassigning network addresses, in this case IP addresses, from one physical device to another. When a VM moves to another physical server, the IP addresses move with it. IP based storage, such as iSCSI, leverages the built in capabilities of TCP/IP over Ethernet to migrate network port addresses without interruption to applications.

Flexibility. Most data centers require a mixture of applications that access either file or block data. With server virtualization, it is likely that you’ll require access to file and block data types on the same physical server for either the guest or parent OS. The ability to use a common network infrastructure for both the guest and parent can reduce cost and simplify management. Ethernet offers support for multiple storage protocols. In addition to iSCSI, Ethernet supports NFS and CIFS/SMB resulting in greater choice to optimize application performance within your budget. FCoE is also supported on an enhanced 10Gb Ethernet network to offer access to an existing FC infrastructure. The added flexibility to interface with existing SAN resources enhances the value of 10Gb as a long-term networking solution.

Performance. Cost. Ubiquity. Other factors that enhance Ethernet storage and therefore IP storage adoption include a robust roadmap, favorable economics, and near universal adoption. The Ethernet roadmap includes 40Gb and 100Gb speeds which will support storage traffic and will be capable of addressing any foreseeable application requirements. Ethernet today offers considerable economic value as port prices continue to drop. Although Gb speeds offer sufficient bandwidth for most business applications, the cost per Gb of bandwidth with 10 Gigabit Ethernet (GbE) is now lower than GbE and therefore offers upside in cost and efficiency. Finally, nearly all new digital devices including mobile phones, cameras, laptops, servers, and even some home appliances, are being offered with WiFi connectivity over Ethernet. Consolidating onto a single network technology means that the networking infrastructure to the rest of the world is essentially already deployed. How good is that?

Some may view moving to a shared network as kind of scary. The concerns are real. But, Ethernet has been a shared networking platform for decades and continues to offer enhanced features, performance, and security to address its increased application. And just because it can share other traffic, doesn’t mean that it must. Physical isolation of Ethernet networks is just as feasible as any other networking technology. Some may choose this option. Regardless, selecting a single network technology, even if not shared across all applications, can reduce not only capital expense, but also operational expense. Your IT personnel can be trained on a single networking technology versus multiple specialized single purpose networks. You may even be able to reduce maintenance and inventory costs to boot.

Customers looking to architect their network and storage infrastructure for today and the future would do well to consider Ethernet and IP storage protocols. The advantages are pretty compelling.

Ethernet Storage Market Momentum Continues

The inexorable growth of the market for Ethernet storage continued in the first half of 2010 – in fact we’re getting very close to Ethernet storage being the majority of networked storage in the Enterprise.

According to IDC’s recent Q2 2010 Worldwide Storage Systems Hardware Tracker, Ethernet Storage (NAS plus iSCSI) revenue market share climbed to 45%, up from 39% in 2009, 32% in 2008 and 28% in 2007, as shown below.

2007

2008

2009

Q2 2010

FC SAN

72%

68%

61%

55%

iSCSI SAN

6%

10%

13%

15%

NAS

22%

22%

26%

30%

In terms of capacity market share, we have already see the crossover point, with Ethernet Storage at 52% of the total PB shipped, up from 47% in 2009, 42% in 2008 and 37% in 2007, as shown in the following table.

2007

2008

2009

Q2 2010

FC SAN

62%

58%

53%

48%

iSCSI SAN

8%

13%

15%

18%

NAS

29%

29%

32%

34%

Ethernet Storage Market Momentum Continues in First Half of 2010

The inexorable growth of the market for Ethernet storage continued in the first half of 2010 – in fact we’re getting very close to Ethernet storage being the majority of networked storage in the Enterprise.

According to IDC’s recent Q2 2010 Worldwide Storage Systems Hardware Tracker, Ethernet Storage (NAS plus iSCSI) revenue market share climbed to 45%, up from 39% in 2009, 32% in 2008 and 28% in 2007, as shown below.

2007

2008

2009

Q2 2010

FC SAN

72%

68%

61%

55%

iSCSI SAN

6%

10%

13%

15%

NAS

22%

29%

26%

30%

In terms of capacity market share, we have already see the crossover point, with Ethernet Storage at 52% of the total PB shipped, up from 47% in 2009, 42% in 2008 and 37% in 2007, as shown in the following table.

2007

2008

2009

Q2 2010

FC SAN

62%

58%

53%

48%

iSCSI SAN

8%

13%

15%

18%

NAS

29%

29%

32%

34%

Share

SNIA Cloud Activities for 2010

Given that it’s the middle of summer it may be hot where you are, but the SNIA Cloud activities are heating up for the remainder of this year, and you don’t want to be left out.

SNIA Summer Symposium

At the end of July every year SNIA hosts a Symposium in San Jose for all the groups. The Cloud Storage TWG will be meeting from Monday afternoon through Thursday morning. The agenda is posted publicly and non-SNIA members are encouraged to attend.

Also at the Symposium Monday night is a Birds of Feather (BOF) session where we will be doing a demo of CDMI and OCCI working together in a common infrastructure. There will be time for details on the implementation and discussion afterward.

Thursday morning will be a special session to update folks on the SNIA Cloud activities for the remainder of the year. Besides the in person session at the Symposium, the session will also be broadcast as an online Webinar for folks who cannot make it in person. More information and a registration link is available on the SNIA Website.

Storage Developer Conference

#alttext#
In September will be the annual Storage Developer Conference (SDC) and this year Cloud is a big part of the agenda. There will be a CDMI Plugfest throughout the week, a Cloud Hands on Lab for developers, and Cloud Tracks all week including some big cloud related keynotes. But *wait* there’s more. Following SDC at the same hotel on Thursday September 23rd will be the…

SNIA Cloud Burst Event

#alttext# This is an event that is squarely focused on Cloud Storage and brings together end users, cloud providers and storage vendors for a unique experience including demos, a showcase and in depth sessions on this part of the overall cloud industry. More information is available on the Cloud Burst page.

Storage Networking World

For the past two SNWs, there has been a Cloud Pavilion with great traffic and interest from the attendees for those that participate. At this fall’s SNW in Dallas, we will repeat this successful program with a limited number of slots. In addition we will again have a hands on lab for cloud that is always well attended (by end users only). If you are looking for a speaking opportunity, please consider being a sponsor of the cloud summit at SNW where end users come to learn about the cloud and the offerings that are available.

SNW Europe

Last year SNW Europe was a huge success for the SNIA Cloud Participants, with a year over year increase in record attendance. This year will see an increasing set of activities around the cloud, including a new Cloud Pavilion and Hands on Labs. There are a limited number of slots for these and they will sell out early. Included is an opportunity for a speaking engagement as well.

“Membership has it’s privileges”

Many of these opportunities are open only to Cloud Storage Initiative (CSI) member companies. The membership fees help to fund these activities for the members and augment the work of the volunteers with paid resources. If you can help get your company involved, please contact Marty Foltyn (marty@bitsprings.com) for more information.